I've been in church since before I could walk. Well, if you want to get specific about it, I've been in church since before I was born. I grew up going to kids church every week, where I learned Bible stories and life lessons. This was on the whole hugely beneficial, but there are a few mindsets I learned from it which I've noticed affecting me unhealthily as I've grown up.
I don't mean to blame my church or my Sunday school teachers. This post isn't a pointed criticism of my childhood church; it's a criticism of what many churches today teach their children that they don't realize is harmful.
Sunday schools try to get children involved in the Bible in any way they can. Teachers plaster classrooms with posters of stories and verses, pick games with costumes and props, and plan crafts to be taken home along with a sheet of verses. The enthusiasm continues up through middle school, where snacks have usually graduated from graham crackers and water (dipped in the water, of course. no? just my church? okay sorry ew gross) to donuts, and students are asked to bring their Bible every Sunday. By high school, usually Sunday mornings only involve teaching, which prepares the student for graduation to "big church." As I look back on my progression through these stages, I don't want to criticize the system. Teaching children about God is important, and teachers must find engaging ways to do this. I only wish to point out two specific practices that I have, looking back, noticed to be harmful.
The first thing is "Bible Swords." Already sounds great, right? Edifying, and all that stuff! Anyway, maybe you haven't played it under this title, but it's a game where kids compete to find a certain scripture verse in the Bible. Whoever finds it the fastest wins. What sort of game is this? Of course, it's supposed to motivate kids to . . . what? Be able to find things quickly in their Bible? Since when is speed helpful in a quiet time? When you get to Big Church, does the adult who finds the verse quickest get to stand up at a microphone and read it for the pastor? Do people in heaven get to sit closer to Jesus if they can find the Psalm quickly when the head angel calls it out?
My guess would be that whoever came up with this game plays it in hopes that the students will want to be able to find things in their Bible quickly, and so will spend more time in their Bible during the week. I'm here to tell you: it doesn't work.
Wrong motivations seldom lead to right habits. If the objective is to be able to find things quickly in their Bible, children will be more likely to buy tabs that have each book of the Bible than to spend an allotted amount of time every other day of the week flipping around their Bible. A game played for ten minutes once a week is not enough reason to spend 10 minutes every other day of the week reading the Bible (or, more likely, flipping to each book for practice). And how would a child even know that the true objective was to read the Bible, if the game's objective was not reading the Bible, but mining it?
The other hope of a Sunday school teacher who encourages this game is perhaps to praise young students who are reading their Bible regularly at home and reward them by letting them beat their classmates. What sort of reward is that? Since when is time with God a competition? If we encourage young students to read their Bible by letting them beat other students who are not reading their Bible, what does this teach? That when we read our Bible, we "win" against other Christians. That when we read our Bible, we are better than other students who don't. This game, rather than encouraging young Christians to seek God through Scripture for renewal and fulfillment, teaches them to seek Scripture for church fame, for points on the "good Christians" board.
The reason I write about this game is because I played it when I was little, and now—yes, even now, as a nineteen-year-old girl—when I flip through my Bible around other people, I compare my speed to theirs. Now, before you try to tell me, I'll tell you: That is pathetic. I don't want to attribute this completely to church—I know that some of it is alllllll me (yay me). But I do want to draw attention to the game, in case any of you (imaginary readers) happen to teach middle school Sunday school, so that you can avoid it. Do you want to encourage your kids to read their Bible at home? Then encourage your kids to read their Bible at home! With actual words! "Hey! Have you read James? You should totally read it this week—it's not too long—and we can talk about it next week together!" Want to encourage the kids who are already reading their Bible at home? Then encourage the kids who are already reading their Bibles at home! Ask them about it; let them share with you what they're learning, and tell them what you're learning!
And do you see what that would do? They would shift the focus from the student and put it on the Word. They put the student in a situation where they are speaking about Christ, which prepares them for the rest of their Christian life of sharing with others what the Lord is teaching them. It gets them comfortable with talking about Scripture and tells them that it is important to read Scripture.
The other thing I have a problem with is having kids memorize Scripture for candy or reward. I mean, what!? Really, yeah, not a good idea. ok. glad we agreed that's ridiculous. again with the mixed motives stuff. and with the messing up their mind for a long time stuff. is scripture not enough reward in itself? come on.